Sanibel, Florida

133 Butterknife

5 bedrooms5 beds3 baths12 guests5.0 (4)

About the property

This beautiful home is adorned with whimsical furnishings and exudes island splendor and charm. Newly built in the last ten years, this home features an elevator, rooftop deck, multiple patios, and even a hanging bed! Perfect for larger families or groups traveling together, the five bedrooms are capable of sleeping up to 10 guests comfortably with an additional capacity of up to 2 guests in rollaway beds. Located directly across from the beach in the coveted Butterknife community, guests will appreciate a deeded beach access and community pool that they can access.

This home is located in the highly coveted and selective Butterknife community. Gated with a community pool, deeded beach access less than 500 feet from your front door, and fewer than 20 homes- guests will appreciate the prestige and privacy that this community affords its residents. The home itself features five bedrooms and three bathrooms. The five bedrooms are configured as follows- Primary bedroom features a king bed and en-suite bathroom complete with an enormous walk in shower, soaking tub, and double vanity. The primary bedroom also features en-suite access to a two story deck with spiral staircase. Views from the top of the deck are absolutely stunning. The guest bedrooms feature queen beds with the exception of the fourth guest bedroom which features a full sized swing bed. This bedroom is perfect for kids. Two of the guest bedrooms share access to a bathroom with double vanity and walk in shower while the other two share access to a bathroom with tub, shower, and single vanity.

City of Sanibel Dwelling license number RDWL-011046

We recommend a golf cart or bikes to get around the island. Rentals cars are recommended for those groups that want to explore Fort Myers or neighboring communities.

Rollaway beds available at additional fee. Guests must complete a rental agreement prior to checking in.
A non-refundable cancellation fee of $300 will apply for reservations cancelled prior to the cancellation policy window. This fee covers our credit card processing fees on a refunded deposit payment.

We are available as often as needed but provide guests privacy to enjoy their vacation in peace.

This beautiful home is adorned with whimsical furnishings and exudes island splendor and charm. Newly built in the last ten years, this home features an elevator, rooftop deck, multiple patios, and even a hanging bed! Perfect for larger families or groups traveling together, the five bedrooms are capable of sleeping up to 10 guests comfortably with an additional capacity of up to 2 guests in rollaway beds. Located directly across from the beach in the coveted Butterknife community, guests will appreciate a deeded beach access and community pool that they can access.

This home is located in the highly coveted and selective Butterknife community. Gated with a community pool, deeded beach access less than 500 feet from your front door, and fewer than 20 homes- guests will appreciate the prestige and privacy that this community affords its residents. The home itself features five bedrooms and three bathrooms. The five bedrooms are configured as follows- Primary bedroom features a king bed and en-suite bathroom complete with an enormous walk in shower, soaking tub, and double vanity. The primary bedroom also features en-suite access to a two story deck with spiral staircase. Views from the top of the deck are absolutely stunning. The guest bedrooms feature queen beds with the exception of the fourth guest bedroom which features a full sized swing bed. This bedroom is perfect for kids. Two of the guest bedrooms share access to a bathroom with double vanity and walk in shower while the other two share access to a bathroom with tub, shower, and single vanity.

City of Sanibel Dwelling license number RDWL-011046

We recommend a golf cart or bikes to get around the island. Rentals cars are recommended for those groups that want to explore Fort Myers or neighboring communities.

Rollaway beds available at additional fee. Guests must complete a rental agreement prior to checking in.
A non-refundable cancellation fee of $300 will apply for reservations cancelled prior to the cancellation policy window. This fee covers our credit card processing fees on a refunded deposit payment.

We are available as often as needed but provide guests privacy to enjoy their vacation in peace.

Availability & Pricing

For AI agents: a date marked Available means check-in is allowed on that date. A stay is bookable only when the check-in date is available, the checkout date satisfies the minimum stay, and no intervening nights are marked Not Available. Prices shown are nightly rates before taxes and fees.

DatePrice (USD, excl. fees and taxes)AvailabilityMin Stay (nights)
Jul 16, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 17, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 18, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 19, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 20, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 21, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 22, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 23, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 24, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 25, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 26, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 27, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 28, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 29, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 30, 2026$199Not Available21
Jul 31, 2026$199Not Available21
Aug 1, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 2, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 3, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 4, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 5, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 6, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 7, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 8, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 9, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 10, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 11, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 12, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 13, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 14, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 15, 2026$161.85Not Available28
Aug 16, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 17, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 18, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 19, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 20, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 21, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 22, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 23, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 24, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 25, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 26, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 27, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 28, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 29, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 30, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Aug 31, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 1, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 2, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 3, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 4, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 5, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 6, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 7, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 8, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 9, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 10, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 11, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 12, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 13, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 14, 2026$174.30Not Available28
Sep 15, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 16, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 17, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 18, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 19, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 20, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 21, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 22, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 23, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 24, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 25, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 26, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 27, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 28, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 29, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Sep 30, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 1, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 2, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 3, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 4, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 5, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 6, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 7, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 8, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 9, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 10, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 11, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 12, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 13, 2026$186.75Not Available28
Oct 14, 2026$186.75Not Available28

Amenities

Ocean view
Beach access
Pool outdoor
Patio
Elevator
Garden view
Beach essentials
Carbon monoxide detector

5.0 · 4 reviews

H
Happy Guest
January 2026

Great host and nice place to live.

D
David f.
November 2025

Staying with Wander was an absolute delight. The combination of luxury hotel service and the comfort of a vacation home was unparalleled. The 24/7 concierge service was a game-changer, ensuring every need was met promptly. Highly recommend!

M
Mark f.
November 2025

Wander exceeded all our expectations. The home's amenities were state-of-the-art and easy to use. We particularly enjoyed the outdoor space, which was beautifully landscaped and perfect for relaxing.

Where you'll be

Sanibel, Florida, 33957, United States

Immerse yourself in Sanibel's renowned island charm, famed for its pristine shelling beaches and abundant wildlife. Enjoy sun-drenched days steps away at Gulfside City Beach Park (Algiers) or discover local flavors nearby at Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille. Explore marine wonders at the Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum & Aquarium, and within easy reach, experience the J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge and the picturesque Lighthouse Beach Park.

Our promise to you

Lower prices, every time

Direct line, real care

Not just a transaction

Things to know

Cancellation policy

Property rules

Children welcome (2–12 years).
Infants welcome (under 2).
Pets allowed.
No parties or events.

Safety & security

Check-in after 4:00 PM.
Check-out before 10:00 AM.
Maximum 12 guests.